Treasure Coast Pet Sitters Local Moms Recommend

Between work trips, family visits, and the occasional weekend away, finding someone reliable to watch your pets can feel surprisingly hard to nail down. Not because there’s a shortage of options, but because handing over your house key (and your dog’s daily eye drops) takes real trust.

We asked Treasure Coast moms who they trust with their pets. A few names came up again and again, while others received enthusiastic recommendations from families who have relied on them for everything from daily walks to medication administration and extended trips.

Here’s who local moms recommend…and why.

Pet Sitters Treasure Coast Moms Recommended Most

A few names came up repeatedly across separate recommendations.

Cathy Stiner, The Perfect Pet Sitter

Phone: 772-777-8030

Cathy Stiner was one of the most frequently recommended names in the conversation. A 2024 Choice Awards winner in the Pet Sitting category, she received particularly strong praise from longtime clients.

One mom described Cathy as “our one and only, for many years,” while another said she “treats our pets like they are her own.”

Jenny and the Pets

Jennifer RenfroPhone: 201-259-8082Service Area: Stuart, Palm City, Jensen Beach, and Port St. Lucie

Jenny and the Pets was another name that came up repeatedly. One local mom shared that Jennifer and her team have cared for her four cats and husky for four years and said she’s consistently had a great experience.

The business is licensed, bonded, and insured and offers dog walking, in-home visits, and overnight care. Clients can also receive daily photo and text updates through the company’s app.

At the time this information was provided, pricing included:

• Dog walks: $25 per walk, plus $5 per additional pet
• In-home visits: $25 per visit, plus $5 per additional pet
• Overnight care: Starting at $80 per night

Pricing and availability can change, so contact the provider directly for current rates.

Jenn Hager

Jenn Hager was another name that resurfaced in recommendations, with local moms describing her as “the greatest” and someone who “will take care of her as her own.”

Waggin’ Tails Ranch

Phone: 772-341-9499

Waggin’ Tails Ranch is a retired-firefighter, family-owned business offering several options depending on what works best for your pet, including overnight stays at its 5-acre ranch, daycare, and in-home visits.

The business was described as pet insured and Pet First Aid and CPR certified, making it one to consider asking about if your pet has additional care needs.

Mermaid & Bear Pet Concierge

Karen Hopping

Mermaid & Bear Pet Concierge is a fully licensed and insured concierge service that also received strong praise from local pet owners.

At the time these recommendations were collected, Karen was reportedly booking into 2027, so families interested in her services may want to inquire well in advance.

Pricing provided at the time included:

• Dog walk/nanny visit: $50 for 45–60 minutes, plus $10 per additional dog
• Overnight retreats: $175 per night for the first two nights, $150 per night for nights 3–6, and $125 per night for stays of 7+ nights, plus $25 per additional dog
• Cat visits: $35 for 45 minutes, plus $20 per additional critter

Contact the provider directly to confirm current pricing and availability before booking.

More Local Pet Sitters to Know

A few additional names Treasure Coast moms recommended:

• Candi Cares Pet Services — Serving Stuart and Palm City with overnight, daily, and personalized stays. 772-300-9205
• Krissy Taylor, In-Home Pet Sitter — Serving Martin, Palm Beach, and St. Lucie counties. Recommended for experience with dogs, cats, horses, livestock, and medication administration. 302-275-2027
• Saige’s Pet Sitting LLC (Emily Persaud) — Offers boarding and drop-in services. 772-203-0852

Have a Pet With Medical Needs?

One local mom specifically needed a sitter for a dog requiring multiple daily eye drops. Instead of eliminating in-home pet sitting as an option, she found several local sitters who had relevant experience, including caring for diabetic pets requiring twice-daily insulin.

If your pet requires medication or has ongoing medical needs, don’t assume pet sitting is automatically off the table. Instead, ask potential sitters about their specific experience with your pet’s medication, condition, and care routine.

Depending on your pet’s needs, you may also want to ask about Pet First Aid/CPR training and what the sitter would do if your pet experienced a medical emergency while you were away.

What to Ask Before You Book a Pet Sitter

• Are you insured and bonded?
• Can you provide references from other local pet owners?
• What experience do you have with my type of pet?
• Are you comfortable administering my pet’s specific medication, if needed?
• Are you trained in Pet First Aid or CPR?
• What’s your backup plan if you’re sick or unavailable on a scheduled day?
• Do you send photo or text updates during visits?
• What happens if my pet becomes sick or injured while I’m away?
• What exactly is included in the price?
• Are there additional charges for multiple pets, holidays, medications, or extended visits?

Quick Tips

• Book early, especially around holidays and school breaks. Popular local sitters can fill their schedules surprisingly far in advance.
• Schedule a meet-and-greet before your first booking. This is especially important if your pet has medical, behavioral, or anxiety-related needs.
• Confirm pricing upfront. Rates can vary considerably between walks, drop-in visits, overnight stays, additional pets, and holiday bookings.
• Discuss your pet’s routine in detail. Feeding schedules, medications, favorite hiding spots, walking habits, and even little quirks can be helpful for someone caring for your pet for the first time.
• Leave emergency information. Make sure your sitter has your veterinarian’s information, an emergency contact, and clear instructions about what you’d like them to do if something happens while you’re away.

Final Thought

Whether you need someone for a quick weekend away, daily visits while you’re at work, or an extended trip, finding a pet sitter you trust can make leaving home a whole lot easier.

And sometimes the best place to start is with the people who’ve already handed over their own house keys.

These are the pet sitters Treasure Coast moms recommended based on their own experiences. From longtime sitters families have relied on for years to services equipped for overnight stays and pets with medication needs, there’s a range of local options worth exploring.

Check out what local moms are saying about pet insurance.

How We Created This List: These recommendations came from Treasure Coast parents sharing their personal experiences with local pet sitters. Inclusion does not constitute a guarantee or endorsement of any provider. Services, pricing, availability, insurance, certifications, and other business information can change. Always verify current information directly with the provider before booking.